SpongeBob is seen in his house, asking Gary to help him pick out an outfit for a party. SpongeBob starts looking for one inside a treasure chest and finds a yodeler outfit, but Gary doesn't like it, so SpongeBob looks for another one. He finds a Tarzan outfit, but Gary doesn't like it either. So SpongeBob looks for another one and finds a knight outfit, but Gary doesn't like that one either. Finally, SpongeBob just decides to go as himself and Gary agrees and then the short ends.