He retains most of his appearance as SpongeBob except he wears a red headband and blue speedo.
Short Order Boy and Pink Patty compete against the undefeated champions, Jim and the Purple wrestler with Mr. Krabs as their manager. The two are reluncant to fight at first, but Krabs manages to convince them that their opponents are "pretending."
Short Order Boy and Pink Patty get beaten up by their opponents, including both being jammed inside of a bucket and punched repetitively. Eventually, they are put into a "sleeper hold" and were wide open for the champion's ultimate attack, the Flying Double Decker Atomic Headbutt of Destruction. Fortunately, Pink Patty's iron butt managed to not only block the attack but crumble up the champions into pieces and are swept away.
Short Order Boy and Pink Patty win the match and are the new champions, much to Mr. Krabs' delight. However, they choose to go to Wrestle Camp instead of receiving the one-million dollars.