SpongeBob and Patrick are making a pie made up of apples, candy, a Krabby Patty, a bunch of toys, a bone from Gary's food and Patrick's pants, mixed with SpongeBob's shoes. SpongeBob puts the pie on the grill, and Patrick comes, taking the pie without gloves, burning his hands. SpongeBob takes the pie with gloves, and places it on the windowsill, where Squidward sees it and eats it. SpongeBob asks Squidward if he had seen the pie. Squidward says: "I'm sure it will turn up." However, he accidentially belches up Patrick's pants in a bubble. It ends with Patrick saying "My Pants."