Done in the style of the classic noir mystery films, the short begins with SpongeBob wondering why he is called "GumShoe SquarePants," after which he steps on a piece of gum, thus realizing why he is called that way. He inspects it and chews it. After that, he accidentally smashes Plankton.
SpongeBob does not want to be known as “PlanktonShoe SquarePants," so he decides to smear Plankton off of his shoe like he is dog feces.
He then walks away, claiming that he has another mystery to solve: where he is right now.
|( ‣ ) Associated production music|
|( • ) Original music|
|( ◦ ) SpongeBob music|
• ? [Plays throughout]