After SpongeBob fails his driving test, he decides to cheer up Mrs. Puff by taking her to a square dance. At the square dance, SpongeBob screws up while dancing and causes a person to go through a wall. SpongeBob was told by the police man that he is no longer allowed to square dance.
Mrs. Puff decides to take Mr. Krabs out on a picnic because of the deed SpongeBob tried to do. On the picnic, she brings homemade seaweed pie. Once she tells him about the pie, Mr. Krabs says he is allergic to it. At the hospital, he has to pay a hospital bill.
After the good deed from Mrs. Puff, he decides to do a good deed. Pearl ran in, crying because she has to baby sit kids and there's a dance at the same time. Mr. Krabs decides to babysit for her while she's at the dance. At the house, they had 26 kids. The kids did bad things like swallowing crayons, screaming, and painting the rug. At bed time, Mr. Krabs tells them a bedtime story about Davy Jones. The kids started crying and when the parents came home, they sent him home with no pay.
Pearl liked the good deed her dad did for him, so she decided to do a good deed herself. For her good deed, she decides to get Squidward a pet worm from the shelter. Pearl went to the mall and when she came back, Squidward was not happy because the worm ate all the food. Squidward decides to play his clarinet and the worm started dancing then Squidward liked it.
The cover takes place on a pier and shows SpongeBob scared and a picture from the episode "Krusty Towers" with Mr. Krabs badly injured in the hospital.