Squidward will give SpongeBob an order, and the player has to click on a patty to put it on the grill, click it to flip it when it's nearly cooked, and then click it when fully cooked to put it on a bun before it burns.
Then the player has to add cheese, lettuce, pickles, ketchup, mustard, mayo, and finally the top bun to the patty. Squidward will then take the complete patty, and points are rewarded to the player.
Occasionally, Patrick will appear and eat a Krabby Patty, causing SpongeBob to restart cooking that patty. Some orders from Squidward may ask for a specific ingredient (like mayo) to be left out. The player loses when time runs out.