Encyclopedia SpongeBobia
Register
Advertisement
Encyclopedia SpongeBobia

Wiki
Proposal Archive

The following proposal has been discussed and is now marked as resolved. The page has been protected and now serves as an archive. Do not edit this page.
Date Resolved: October 18, 2015


Result: Closed. If this test drive turns out to be successful, it will pass.


Introduction

User:AMK152 has endorsed this discussion.  AW10  Talk  Contribs  E-Mail  12:38,10/4/2015 

Proposal

This is a proposal for the new discussion system.

The proposal is actually an example discussion page where you can experiment with the system, but you must leave "Introduction" section untouched, since it is actually another part of the proposal.

The page I have linked is exactly how discussion page will look like if this proposal passes. So I am proposing discussion page with "Introduction" section explaining the discussion process no matter what the topic of discussion is, "Proposal" section where topic of discussion is explained, and "Concerns" section where people can put their concerns during the discussion stage.

Well, the whole system has two stages, discussion stage and post-discussion stage. In the discussion stage, as "Introduction" section says, all concerns that have been brought during the discussion stage must be resolved before the stage is complete. Then, in the post-discussion stage, original proposer takes resolution of all concerns into account and create a new proposal* that will be voted.

If this passes, we will get rid of petitions and endorsements for creating discussion. Well, everyone will be able to create discussions and the system will then filter out bad discussion ideas. Well, with this new discussion system, relying on resolving all concerns about initial proposal, even the worst discussion ideas can either be "doomed" or turned into something amazing.

Discussion will end at Midnight UTC on October 11, 2015.
________________
* That new proposal will be created as "ESB:Proposal/<replace-with-title-of-the-proposal>" and will be voted with {{Support}}", "{{Neutral}}" and "{{Oppose}}".

 AW10  Talk  Contribs  E-Mail  23:17,10/8/2015 

Templates used

Template:DiscussionIntroductionSection|Concerns
Template:DiscussionIntroductionSection|Voting

Template:DiscussionConcernHeading
Template:DiscussionConcernImporter

Template:CreateNewConcernButton
Template:CreateNewVoteButton

Template:CreateNewConcernButton/comment
Template:CreateNewConcernButton/Concern<1-20>

Template:CreateNewVoteButton/support
Template:CreateNewVoteButton/neutral
Template:CreateNewVoteButton/oppose

Template:DiscussionBoxBegin
Template:DiscussionBoxEnd

Template:DiscussionBoxIndentBegin
Template:DiscussionBoxIndentEnd

Template:Button
Template:Percent
Template:Clear

Discussion

Support

  • Support Support - Now this is the sort of thing I had in mind. :) --Spongebob456 talk 14:14, October 4, 2015 (UTC)
  • Support Support - I definitely agree with your idea. Petitions have got to go!  Sawpog46  Talk  Contribs  E-Mail  16:56,10/4/2015  16:56, October 4, 2015 (UTC)
  • Support Support - I like it! — AMK152 (Wall • Contrib) 18:08, October 4, 2015 (UTC)
  • Support Support -  120d  Talk  Contribs  120d 23:36, October 8, 2015 (UTC) 
  • Support Support - Patrick Star (Oh My....) 08:50, October 9, 2015 (UTC)

Oppose

  • Oppose Oppose - Now that I've seen the section regarding petitions, I highly disagree with this. PrezDubs messagewall 11:07, October 9, 2015 (UTC)

Neutral

Koolkitty Talk Contribs Edits


ChocolateBrownieBoy Talk Contribs Edits


Comments

Probably dispose.



Advertisement